How To Think Like A Game Designer
Alien: Isolation's save change is sourced to a Game Developer article; MDA comes from a 2004 paper, both in the description.
Caveat: The claim that MDA reliably predicts how players feel is the author's view; he admits only playtests confirm it.
Key takeaways
- 0:00 Alien: Isolation first used auto checkpoints, then switched to slow manual save points because players stopped fearing death.
- 1:33 MDA splits a game into mechanics, dynamics and aesthetics. Here, aesthetics means the player's feelings, not the graphics.
- 5:10 Chosen mechanics should fit a one-line vision, such as Subnautica's "thrill of the unknown" or DOOM's "push forward combat".
- 10:12 Aesthetics are subjective: the same scoring or timer can excite one player and stress another, so playtesting is needed.
The video in brief
- 0:00 The team used automatic checkpoints, then saw players roam without fear. Design director Gary Napper said they suited Call of Duty or Bioshock but not a horror game.
- 1:33 Mark Brown explains the 2004 framework: mechanics are rules and numbers, dynamics are player behaviour, aesthetics are feelings. He shows it with ammo limits, then Zelda's breaking swords.
- 5:04 Flower dropped level-ups and timers to keep calm. Subnautica, Resident Evil Village, FTL and DOOM used a vision statement to choose mechanics, music and visuals.
- 8:28 Games hold hundreds of mechanics that can clash, as in The Callisto Protocol. Players may behave unexpectedly, emotions may change over time, and aesthetics are subjective.
- 10:58 Alien: Isolation moved to few, slow manual saves, which made saving tense. Brown concludes that borrowed mechanics must fit the intended emotions.
What it's about
The video argues that before borrowing a mechanic from another game, a designer should ask what behaviour and feeling it creates (the MDA framework) and whether that fits the game's vision. It sells nothing.
What the video doesn't say
- The video does not cover critiques of MDA; commenters raise them
Claim map
Cited source: Game Developer deep dive on Alien: Isolation's save system, in description
Counter-argument: Napper's interview explains the team's reasoning. No player data is shown, so how strong the effect was is not measured.
Cited source: MDA paper (2004), in description
Counter-argument: Brown himself says you cannot be sure of player reactions without a lot of playtesting. Two commenters also argue MDA is limited as a framework.
Cited source: Jenova Chen interview, CGMagazine, in description
Counter-argument: It shows one case where removal worked. It does not show that borrowed mechanics usually fail or that vision statements guarantee a better game.
Cited source: GDC talk on push forward combat in DOOM, in description
Counter-argument: The vision phrase comes from the developers' talk. Whether every element supports it is the narrator's reading.
Interests at stake
- Mentioned verbally : Platformer Toolkit (his own interactive video essay) (creator's product) 8:35
No sponsor or affiliate link detected. The description only asks viewers to support the channel for bonus content, and Brown mentions his own Platformer Toolkit.
Install Unsaid (free)